Environmental advocates are raising concerns over a recent deal struck between the Beer Store and grocery retailers, warning that Ontario’s successful deposit return scheme may be in jeopardy. The gradual disappearance of Beer Store locations across the province not only impacts alcohol purchases but also reduces the number of drop-off points for consumers to return empty containers and reclaim their deposits.
While grocers with alcohol permits were slated to begin accepting empties in the upcoming year, a newly reached agreement exempts them from this responsibility. This shift in operations has led to the emergence of Beer Store deserts in certain neighborhoods and regions, potentially leading to decreased engagement in the recycling initiative.
Karen Wirsig, a senior program manager at Environmental Defence, expressed alarm over the situation, emphasizing the vital role of the Beer Store program in facilitating the return of refillable containers over the past century. On the contrary, Ministry of Finance spokesperson Scott Blodgett hailed the agreement as a positive development for businesses and consumers, sidestepping inquiries regarding reduced access to return facilities and potential declines in participation rates.
The Beer Store, renowned for its successful deposit return program dating back to 1927, has witnessed a shift in dynamics following the Ontario government’s expansion of alcohol sales beyond its confines, resulting in the closure of numerous outlets. Despite the company’s collection of 1.6 billion alcohol containers in 2024, the changing landscape poses challenges to the program’s efficacy.
To address the evolving scenario, a preliminary agreement between grocers and the Beer Store offers the option for grocery stores to engage the Beer Store in administering the deposit return process for a fee. While this arrangement has been hailed as beneficial by John Nock, president of the Beer Store employee union, it is expected to lead to a reduction in the return of bottles and cans.
Furthermore, the agreement mandates the Beer Store to ensure a return point within 10 kilometers of the majority of Ontarians, a significant increase from previous targets. However, concerns linger over access limitations, especially in urban centers where closures have left communities devoid of nearby return facilities. The potential consequence of these developments could result in a higher number of unredeemed deposits, raising questions about the allocation of these funds for program expansion.
Despite the uncertainties surrounding the future of Beer Store outlets, the company remains noncommittal about potential closures in 2026, maintaining a stance of evaluating decisions based on evolving circumstances.